2019 Sunscreen Product Ratings
Picking a sunscreen can be daunting. You want a product that protects you from the sun that also feels comfortable on your skin. This season there is new information to consider when making your product selection. In February, the Journal of American Medical Association published a study demonstrating that sunscreens are readily absorbed into the blood stream through the skin. The study suggested we need further research to understand the impact the sunscreens may have on our health.
Many people know that I have always been one to do my homework when making purchases. In light of the new information about the absorption of sunscreens into our bloodstream, I reevaluated the products I have been using. This year I used a combination of Consumer Report’s top picks, Amazon top sellers and Environmental Working Group (EWG) safety ratings to identify quality products. Because of the safety concerns with aerosolized nanoparticles I did not research spray sunscreens. My recommendation is to avoid them all together. Read more about the criteria I use for evaluating sunscreens.
The EWG rates product based on ingredients safety and efficiency with the best score being a 1 and the worse score being a 10. The Consumer Report assigns an an overall score based on aggregate information from testing of UVA protection, SPF rating and variation from SFP rating claims. A higher Consumer Report number is better.
Amazon sunscreens with 1500 or more ratings and an average score of 4+ stars.
Contains oxybenzone and similar derivatives
Easy application and dry touch formula makes it a crowd favorite
$2.00/fl. oz.
EWG safety rating: 5
Consumer Report Rating: 76
Sun Bum Original Moisturizing Sunscreen SPF 30 Lotion
Contains methylisothiazolinone, a skin allergen not allowed in leave-on products in Europe.
Easy application and dry touch formula makes it a crowd favorite.
$1.88/fl. oz.
EWG safety rating: 4
Consumer Report Rating: Unrated
Blue Lizard Australian Sunscreen - Sensitive Sunscreen SPF 30+ Broad Spectrum UVA/UVB Protection
Contains Zinc Oxide and Titanium Oxide which are safe for people and the ocean.
$3.70/fl. oz.
EWG safety rating: 1
Consumer Report Rating: 50
Thinkbaby Safe Sunscreen SPF 50+
Contains Zinc Oxide and Titanium Oxide which are safe for people and the ocean.
$4.32/fl. oz.
EWG safety rating: 1
Consumer Report Rating: 41
Consumer Report’s Professional Top Rated Products:
La Roche-Pasay Anthelios 60 Melt-in Sunscreen Milk
Contains avobenzone and similar derivatives
$7.20/fl. oz
EWG safety rating: 3
Consumer Report rating: 100
BullFrog Land Sport Quik Gel SPF 50
Contains oxybenzone and similar derivatives
$2.50/fl. oz.
EWG rating: Unrated
Consumer Report Rating: 95
Coppertone Ultra Guard Lotion SPF 70
Contains oxybenzone and similar derivatives
$1.00/fl. oz.
EWG rating: 7
Consumer Report Rating: 94
Equate (Walmart) Ultra Lotion SPF 50
Contains oxybenzone and similar derivatives
$0.44/fl. oz
EWG rating: 7
Consumer Reports Rating: 94
California Kids Supersensitive Lotion SPF 30+
Contains Zinc Oxide and Titanium Oxide which are safe for people and the ocean.
$6.90/fl. oz
EWG rating: 2
Consumer Report Rating: 55
Badger Active Natural Mineral Cream SPF 30 Unscented
Contains Zinc Oxide and Titanium Oxide which are safe for people and the ocean.
$5.52/fl. oz
EWG rating: 1
Consumer Reports Rating: 55
So what is my final pick? As you can see the choice is challenging. When I take into consideration effectiveness, safety and price I plan to use Badger Active Natural or California Kids lotion this summer.
(This blog post is not sponsored by any manufacturer. However, Relish Health may receive a commission on purchases made through an Amazon link.)